Rolling Stone critic Ed Naha called "Shooting Star" the "
pièce de résistance" of
Straight Shooter and "the highpoint of [Paul Rodgers'] writing career." Naha states that "Rodgers nearly assumes the role of the
Harry Chapin of crotch rock as he casually recounts the chilling tale of a young rock star … from beginning to end" and that the "calculated effect of the song is made stronger by its low-keyed approach to melodrama." Stephen Thomas Erlewine described it as one of the two "big hits" from
Straight Shooter (along with "
Feel Like Makin' Love") and a "classic rock staple".
Greenville News critic Donna Isbell Walker agreed that it is a "radio staple".
Ultimate Classic Rock critic Matt Wardlaw rated it as Bad Company's 3rd best song, saying that it "acts as a cautionary tale about what can happen when a big dreamer gets more success than he can handle."
Classic Rock critic Malcolm Dome rated it as Bad Company's 4th best song, calling it "an epic tale of the rise and fall of a rock star."
Classic Rock History critic Janey Roberts rated it as Bad Company's 5th best song. ==Legacy==