Times Square became the epicenter for large-scale theater productions between 1900 and
the Great Depression. Manhattan's theater district had begun to shift from
Union Square and
Madison Square during the first decade of the 20th century. Before the theaters were built, the Times Square area had been largely residential, containing brownstone townhouses and some commercial tenants. Though the New had been completed in 1909, Ames and the theater's founders saw the venue, on the
Upper West Side, as being too large and too far away from Times Square. The New Theatre's founders acquired several buildings at 219–225 West 44th Street and 218–230 West 45th Street in March 1911 for the construction of a "new New Theatre" there. The theater would have contained a private alley to the east. In April 1912, Winthrop Ames and Lee Shubert decided to lease the site of the new New Theatre from the Astor family. Shubert's venue on 44th Street was named in memory of his late brother
Sam S. Shubert, while Ames's venue on 45th Street was named after actor
Edwin Booth. The entire site was owned by the
Astor family at the time, but Shubert and Ames signed a long-term lease for the land under the theaters in 1912. The Shubert and Booth theaters both opened in 1913. At the time, there were just two other theaters on the surrounding blocks: the Little Theatre and the now-demolished
Weber and Fields' Music Hall. In its early years, the alley was relatively narrow since the Hotel Astor extended much further back into its
land lot than the modern-day One Astor Plaza.
Early popularity The Shubert/Booth alley was used during World War I for charitable and wartime fundraisers. These events often featured the casts of shows that were playing at the Shubert and Booth theaters. The Broadhurst and Plymouth (now Schoenfeld) theaters were built to the west in 1917, with a parallel private alley of their own. These were followed by the
Music Box in 1921; the
Imperial in 1923; the
Martin Beck (now Al Hirschfeld) in 1924; and the Majestic, Masque (Golden), Royale (Jacobs), and
Erlanger's (St. James) in 1927.
Sardi's restaurant on 44th Street, across from Shubert Alley, became a popular meeting place in the Broadway theatrical community. a series of competitions judged by
Al Jolson. During the late 1920s and early 1930s, an old woman nicknamed "The Rose of Shubert Alley" or "Rosie of Shubert Alley" frequently sold goods within the alley. having the color of one of those street scenes from a tropical revue, churning with actors, Broadway reporters, chorus girls, and a soupcon of booking agents and costumers. A
hurdy-gurdy grinds out tunes, and often a street band adds oom-pahs to the medley.... There is good-natured shoving about, hoots, and back-patting. Stars are hailed by first name. Bootleggers are there with their order books. Also racing touts, with hot tips.--> In the 1930s, the alley was bisected by a metal fence. The two sides of the alley carried different names: the west side retained the name "Shubert Alley", while the east side was called "Astor Alley". Cast members at the Shubert and Booth theaters would relax there during their breaks. According to the
New York Herald Tribune, producers without offices also met with performers in the alley. Stylized clocks were installed at either end of the alley in 1948. The clocks, designed by Louis Gottlieb, used the letters of the phrase "Shubert Alley" in place of numerals for the hour marks. A wooden sign was also installed, with the text "In honor of all those who glorify the theater and who use this short thoroughfare, Shubert Alley". By then, Shubert Alley was one of three private thoroughfares in the city that was not a
dead end; the others were
Rockefeller Plaza and Thomas Street.
Renovations The Shuberts bought the site of the Broadhurst, Plymouth, Booth, and Shubert theaters from the Astors in 1948, including their half of Shubert Alley. The brick annex was replaced by a rear entrance to the Hotel Astor, as well as stores on either end. The fence between Shubert and Astor alleys was also demolished, From October 1950 to May 1952, the
United Nations operated an unofficial information center in Shubert Alley, staffed solely by women. The Shuberts allowed the UN to use the alley without paying rent. The project also involved building a condenser atop the Shubert Theatre. For Shubert Alley's 50th anniversary, the Shubert family embedded a plaque in a corner of the Shubert Theatre during a ceremony on October 2, 1963. At the celebration, actress
Helen Hayes said the alley was "a place where an actor can strut after a successful opening, and the only place in all New York to avoid after a bad one." The eastern half of the alley was temporarily fenced off the next year, during the demolition of the hotel, to make way for One Astor Plaza. There was also a proposal to cover Shubert Alley with a glass canopy, but it was not executed.
Late 20th century to present After One Astor Plaza was completed, a northward extension of the alley was proposed in 1969 as part of what would become the
New York Marriott Marquis hotel between 45th and 46th Street. However, the developers of what became the Marquis were unable to acquire the Piccadilly Hotel, thus also blocking the extension. The next year, the
New York City Planning Commission proposed that the alley be lengthened further northward to
53rd Street. When the Marriott Marquis was completed in 1985, its passageway functioned as a northward extension of Shubert Alley. Unlike the original alley, the Marquis extension is completely beneath that hotel. the argument continued for several months and nearly led to a lawsuit. A gift shop called One Shubert Alley opened between the Shubert and Booth theaters in 1979, within three of the Booth's former dressing rooms. Numerous annual events were hosted in the alley starting in the 1980s. During the 2000s, Shubert Organization president
Gerald Schoenfeld also parked his car in the alley, leading mayor
Michael Bloomberg to observe that Schoenfeld had the "best parking spot in New York City". The alley was closed temporarily in 2019 due to falling debris, prompting a renovation that displaced the 2019 Broadway Barks event. As a result of the
COVID-19 pandemic in New York City, two annual events in Shubert Alley were moved online: the Broadway Cares flea market in 2020 and Broadway Barks in 2020 and 2021. ==References==