Haywards Heath Town McMenemy started his career in coaching as manager of
Sussex County League club
Haywards Heath Town.
Philippines Through
Chris Greatwich, one of his former players at club
Lewes, McMenemy heard about the vacant coaching job in the Philippines. Five weeks after applying, he received an offer from the
Philippine Football Federation, the governing body of football in the country, to coach the
Philippines national team. After an undefeated group campaign, one win and two draws, the Philippines qualified second in the group to face the
Indonesia national team in the semi-finals. The team was eventually defeated 2–0 on aggregate with Indonesia's
Cristian Gonzáles scoring a goal in each leg of the semi-final. Both the home and away legs were held in Indonesia as the Philippines didn't have a stadium that met the international standard set by
AFF. The win of the Philippines over the
Vietnam national football team during the group phase of the 2010 AFF Suzuki Cup was ranked as one of the "Top 10 soccer stories of 2010" by columnist Georgina Turner of American sports magazine
Sports Illustrated. McMenemy left the Philippines in January 2011 and was replaced by
German manager
Michael Weiß.
Loyola Meralco Sparks On 26 August 2014, McMenemy was named head coach of the Loyola Meralco Sparks of the United Football League, replacing Vince Santos, who led the team to the 2013 Cup title but was unable to win the more prestigious UFL league titles in the past two years. On 31 January 2015, McMenemy won his first silverware as a professional coach and as a Sparks manager. In December 2016, Loyola announced that McMenemy had left the club.
Bhayangkara Indonesian club
Bhayangkara appointed McMenemy to lead the club as its head coach on 23 December 2016. Bhayangkara won the Indonesian Liga 1 on that moment.
Indonesia On 20 December 2018, McMenemy was appointed by the
Football Association of Indonesia as the head coach of the national team, replacing
Bima Sakti. ==Managerial statistics==