Fletcher Pratt, writing in
The New York Times, found
Sinister Barrier to be a standard adventure story with a scientific background, which moves too fast to let anyone look too closely at parts of the structure."
Astounding reviewer
P. Schuyler Miller praised the novel as "a fast-moving adventure in which punch follows punch from beginning to end." Miller reported that Russell had made more effective use of the ideas of
Charles Fort than almost any other author. In
Astounding: John W. Campbell, Isaac Asimov, Robert A. Heinlein, L. Ron Hubbard, and the Golden Age of Science Fiction, author
Alec Nevala-Lee says it "deserves to be ranked as one of the greatest science fiction novels ever written".
Dave Langford reviewed
Sinister Barrier for
White Dwarf #76, and stated that "SF based on Charles Fort's offbeat speculations. 'I think we're property,' said Fort. Russell translated this into nasty energy beasts who herd us like sheep, and chronicled the results when the facts leak out. Painfully dated, but a must for the collector's library." South Korean writer
Djuna cited the work as one that has significantly influenced them in their youth, at the same time noting that "It hasn’t aged well, and it’s particularly criticized for its racist depiction of Asians". ==References==