As with the majority of the Royal Navy, Balchen was placed in reserve at the war's conclusion and returned to England to await further deployment. Whilst there, he married Susannah Apreece, daughter of an army colonel. The marriage produced six children, two of whom survived into adulthood; Frances, who later married
Temple West (Vice Admiral Temple West) and George, who followed his father into the Navy. In 1701, Balchen was again at sea, commanding the small
fireships HMS
Firebrand and then HMS
Vulcan with Sir
George Rooke's fleet off the Spanish coast at the outbreak of the
War of the Spanish Succession. He was probably engaged during the
Battle of Vigo Bay in 1702, where Rooke's fleet captured a Spanish treasure fleet and was instrumental in the capture of the 56-gun
Modéré, which he went on to briefly command as HMS
Modéré. In 1703, Balchen was transferred to the 44-gun
frigate HMS Adventure in the
North Sea. This was an area of great importance to the British war effort due to the convoys carrying naval supplies from Scandinavia, which crossed it regularly. The commission, however, yielded few opportunities in the way of
prize money. The next year, he was transferred to the 54-gun
HMS Chester, with which he was dispatched to the
West African Coast, a region considered almost as fatal as the West Indies. Surviving once again, Balchen remained in the
Chester and was attached to the convoys bound for
Portugal and
Virginia. Balchen suffered his first defeat on 10 October 1707. Leaving the safety of
Portsmouth harbour, his convoy was ambushed by a French squadron under
Forbin and
Duguay-Trouin, in what became the
Battle at the Lizard. Although the dozen French warships were larger and stronger than the convoy escorts, Balchen took his ship into battle with the other warship captains. This action allowed the merchant convoy time to disperse and escape. The ensuing battle was one-sided, with the French warships battering three English ships into submission over several hours, including Balchen's command, which had been boarded by three French
ships of the line. One British warship escaped, but
HMS Devonshire exploded with the loss of nearly 900 lives. The French captured just 15 merchant ships from the hundreds in the convoy, as most made English ports before their pursuers could catch them. Briefly a prisoner in France, Balchen, as an officer, was allowed to return to England on
parole, where a court martial exonerated him for the loss of his ship and commended him for a brave defence. In 1709, he was formally exchanged for a French officer and returned to naval service, receiving command of the newly built 60-gun
HMS Gloucester in August. Leaving
Spithead on his first cruise in October, he had been at sea for just a few hours when Duguay-Trouin again appeared with a squadron of five ships of the line. Unable to outrun his opponents, Balchen engaged the 74-gun flagship
Lis before being forced to surrender after being dismasted and threatened with boarding. Balchen was exchanged almost immediately and the court martial, once again, exonerated him from all blame for the loss of his ship. He was rewarded for his bravery with command of
HMS Colchester in 1710, in which, on 9 November, Balchen secured his first prize, a 20-gun French privateer which he outran in a
gale. In 1712 and 1713, Balchen was in the
Mediterranean under
Sir John Jennings and returned home in 1713 for a period of unemployment on shore. With the end of the War of the Spanish Succession in 1715, Balchen was returned to sea in the 40-gun frigate
HMS Diamond, which he used in the suppression of
piracy in the West Indies until 1716. The same year, he received the shore position commanding the guardship
HMS Orford in the
Medway. ==War of the Quadruple Alliance==