Neale was the leading Elizabethan historian of his generation. In the opinion of fellow historian, and Neale's own graduate student,
Patrick Collinson, Neale's biography of
Elizabeth I "has yet to be bettered". His painstaking research uncovered the political power of the gentry in
The Elizabethan House of Commons (1949), whilst his 1948
Raleigh Lecture on ‘The Elizabethan political scene’ greatly expanded our knowledge of the politics of the reign. The two volumes on
Elizabeth I and her Parliaments (1953 and 1957) explored the relationship between the Queen and her Parliaments. These were criticised by Sir
Geoffrey Elton who claimed that the main preoccupation of these parliaments was the forming of Bills and the passing of Acts, not conflict between Crown and Parliament. Neale's claims that these parliaments were a landmark in the evolution of Parliament was criticised by medievalists such as
J. S. Roskell. However Collinson notes that the conflicts which Neale wrote about did take place and that Neale's retelling of them made an exciting and unforgettable chapter in English history. ==Other positions held==