In 1934,
Aleš Hrdlička, curator of
anthropology at the
Smithsonian Institution rejected the existence of a race of giants between tall. Hrdlička blamed the "will to believe" for the many reports of giant "discoveries". Hrdlička blamed amateur
anthropologists for being fooled by the bones. He stated that people were most often fooled by the length of the
femur bone because they are often not familiar with human anatomy. Hrdlička also stated that reports of giant skeletons occurred two or three times per month. In 2020
The Columbus Dispatch reported that archeologist, Donald Ball collected articles about giant skeletons, which were purportedly found in burial mounds dating as far back as 1845. He determined that when the claims about giant skeletons were scrutinized they did not reveal giant skeletons. One story in the
Indianapolis Journal reported on August 29, 1883, that a skeleton had been found. Dr. M. M. Adams investigated and concluded that the bones were "not of a giant" and the individual was not "above five feet eight inches in height". He determined that it was a "giant fraud" upon the people.
Internet hoax In 2014, an internet story reported that the Smithsonian Institution had custody of many giant skeletons and destroyed "thousands of giant skeletons" in the early 1900s.
Reuters determined that the origin of the story was a satirical website called
World News Daily Report. A spokesperson for the Smithsonian confirmed that the story was not true. The satirical story claimed that the American Institution of Alternative Archaeology accused the Smithsonian of a coverup. The Associated Press also investigated and determined that the story was false.
Giant of Castelnau . "
Giant of Castelnau" refers to three bone fragments (a
humerus,
tibia, and femoral mid-shaft) discovered by
Georges Vacher de Lapouge in 1890 in the sediment used to cover a
Bronze Age burial
tumulus, and dating possibly back to the
Neolithic. Lapouge determined that the fossil bones may belong to one of
the largest humans known to have existed. However, in 2022, Katherine Hacanyan asserted that this discovery by Lapouge was most likely a
cave bear and not a human, in an undergraduate student paper detailing her examination of photos of the bones.
2024 study In 2019, the Travel Channel series
Code of the Wild aired an episode in which a pre-Columbian skeleton was presented that was allegedly 7 feet tall and
Salasaca storytellers were interviewed that related oral traditions of giants. In 2024, Nicholas Landol used mathematical formula to determine that the individual was actually only between 153.34 cm and 162.37 cm and that due to the disarticulation that a skeleton experiences after death, a skeleton can appear larger than it is. As this was only one sample, they also wrote that "Future analysis remains essential, however, to the evaluation of the Indigenous oral traditions of Ecuador". ==Similar hoaxes outside the United States==