In 1989, Taylor began her acting career on the
Nickelodeon children's television series
Hey Dude in which she portrayed the
lifeguard Melody Hanson. She continued in that role through 1991, while making various guest appearances on other programs and films. In 1996, she portrayed the racist school bully Laura Lizzie in the horror film
The Craft, and also portrayed
Drew Barrymore's cousin, Holly Sullivan, in the 1998 comedy
The Wedding Singer. In 2001, she starred alongside her husband
Ben Stiller in
Zoolander. In July 2006, Taylor's husband Ben Stiller announced plans to direct a
CBS sitcom starring Taylor, but the series never aired. In 2010, Taylor guest starred in
Hannah Montana Forever and the
Hallmark Channel Christmas movie
Farewell Mr. Kringle. In 2013, Taylor reprised her role as Sally Sitwell in two episodes of the revived
fourth season of
Arrested Development. She also guest starred on
Elementary in 2017, playing villainess Gail Lundquist. From 2016 to 2022, Taylor had a recurring role as Gail on
Search Party. In 2021, Taylor joined the cast of
High Desert, an
Apple TV+ series. In 2023, she reunited with her
Hey Dude co-star
David Lascher for the
Hey Dude...The 90s Called! podcast. ==Personal life==