Slayers Great received mostly positive reviews. While the film's animation was universally praised, the reception of its plot and especially wacky humor proved to be the most mixed and divisive of all the
Slayers films. Chris Beveridge of Mania.com, who rated it B+, wrote "there is simply something just fun and enjoyable about this particular movie" as "between the really good looking animation and the quick and snappy storyline, it flows very well," making it a "good fun that doesn’t tax the brain much." According to John Sinnott of
DVD Talk,
Slayers Great has more "laugh out loud moments" than any other film in the franchise, and "a fast moving plot with a lot of action and laughs make this a great entry in the
Slayers series." Mania.com's John Eriani similarly opined this is probably the funniest of the
Slayers films and "there isn't much else to the story but that's what makes this one work so well, it doesn't really slow down in any department." Megan Lavey from that same website gave
Great a perfect score of A for being "absolutely hilarious". Other reviews were more or less critical of the film.
The Video Librarian, which awarded it two-and-half stars out of four, declared it only an optional choice for anyone but
Slayers fans due to its "handsome animation, but less-than-stellar storytelling." Mania.com's Dani Moure gave it a similar rating of B−, writing that "while the plot may not be the most satisfying around, even for a comedy like
Slayers, the characters are as strong as ever and there's a lot of laughs to be had," and added that "if you can put up with the misgivings,
Slayers Great is a lot of fun." However,
Fred Patten of
Animation World Network strongly disapproved of how "unabashedly silly"
Great is, endorsing it "only for those who are already die-hard
Slayers fans" and suggesting to see
Slayers Gorgeous instead. John Huxley of Homemademech called
Great "a flawed but enjoyable experience," saved from mediocrity by its character design and art style, also proposing
Gorgeous as a better alternative to it.
Anime News Network recommended
Great for established
Slayers fans, but suggested that everyone else should see the TV series first, although the review of
The Slayers Movie Box by
DVD Verdict's Brett Cullum called the entire set "a good introduction to the world of
Slayers." ==References==