Small Things like These was generally well received by critics and received starred reviews from
Kirkus Reviews and
Library Journal. Multiple reviewers commented on the moral storytelling, which comes across as "a sort of anti-
Christmas Carol."
Kirkus called the book "[a] stunning feat of storytelling and moral clarity." This depth of the book surprised some reviewers, given that
Small Things like These is a quick read that could be considered a
novella given its length.
Associated Press noted, "Keegan's economy of prose is a marvel ... The book takes just an hour or so to read, but you still feel like you know Bill Furlong by the end and understand why he does what he does. His tale of quiet heroism doesn't require any more words." A similar sentiment was echoed in the
Los Angeles Times, who wrote, "Keegan, whose short stories contain unusual depth and grandeur, is the only contemporary writer who could manage the feat of a completely imagined, structured and sustained world with such brevity
." Reviewers also highlighted Keegan's writing style. Keegan's prose was referred to as "surprisingly powerful," "languid and crystalline" in
Booklist, as well as "quiet and precise, jewel-like in its clarity" and
Damon Galgut wrote in
The Times Literary Supplement: "Keegan knows how to weigh and pace her sentences, and her fine judgement delivers many subtle pleasures ... [she] fully exploits the power of understatement."
Lamorna Ash, writing in
The Guardian, noted that
Small Things like These does "not feel quite as devastating, as lasting, as Keegan’s previous work[.] Perhaps, for the first time in her writing, the lightness here has become too light – is kept too far away from the darkness that lurks at the other side of the town." ==Adaptations ==