On
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 100% based on ten reviews, with a
weighted average rating of 8.1/10.
Critical reception The critics were generally positive, with
Louella Parsons declaring: "It is the most courageous subject ever attempted on the screen".
Walter Winchell wrote: "Its seething quality gets inside of you."
Variety wrote: "The Snake Pit is a standout among class melodramas. Based on Mary Jane Ward's novel, picture probes into the processes of mental illness with a razor-sharp forthrightness, giving an open-handed display of the make-up of bodies without minds and the treatments used to restore intelligence. Clinical detail is stated with matter-of-fact clarity and becomes an important part of the melodramatics."
The Hollywood Reporter wrote: "All the vivid performances of
The Snake Pit are not in the upper division of the cast. There are outstanding moments by Beulah Bondi, an elderly lady who imagines herself wealthy; Ruth Donnelly, another inmate; Betsy Blair, a girl who never speaks; and Howard Freeman, playing a doctor whose thoughtless ways harass the unhappy victims. Author and film critic
Leonard Maltin awarded the film three and a half out of a possible four stars, calling it "gripping" and "one of the first films to deal intelligently with mental breakdown and the painstakingly slow recovery process". Among liberals and leftists the film was received as politically progressive. Thus, the
Communist Party USA's
''People's Daily World'' hailed it as "A Film Achievement" and explained that it "does not foster an argument that the solution to our problems lies in new regiments of psychoanalysts". A contemporaneous account by
Millen Brand, who co-wrote the screenplay, said that leading psychiatrists found the film "sensational". Writing about a special showing arranged for sixty psychiatrists in New York City, Brand told a fellow screenwriter that "the psychiatrists not only were enthusiastic without reserve, but they were swooning around at the lengths to which we had gone to show the real complexity and scope of analytic treatment".
Mary Jane Ward, on whose book the film was based, also expressed support for the screenplay and the film, as did journalist
Albert Deutsch. Other film analysts view it as successful in conveying Ward's view of the uncertainties of post-World War II life and women's roles.
Censorship Due to public concerns that the extras in the film were in fact real mental patients being exploited, the
British censor added a foreword explaining that everyone who appeared on screen was a paid actor and that conditions in British hospitals were unlike those portrayed in the film. The censor also cut 1,000 feet of the film, deleting all sequences involving patients in
straitjackets, and lighter scenes evoking laughter. A group of psychiatric nurses in Britain tried to have the film banned but failed. To counteract the idea that U.K. hospitals were as dismal as those in the U.S., the
Crown Film Unit produced
Out of True, a motion picture showing the positive atmosphere and methods in the U.K. ==Awards==