Critical reception Upon its debut,
My So-Called Life received critical acclaim. Critic Joyce Millman said the show "evokes the emotional turbulence of adolescence with breathtaking accuracy" and is also "unusually perceptive in its portrayal of the push and pull of mother-daughter relationships." Millman added the show has an interesting take on "midlife crisis and marital boredom", and concluded "with bittersweet clarity,
My So-Called Life shows us that teen angst is something we never outgrow."
Steven Spielberg lauded the show and called Danes "one of the most exciting actresses to debut in 10 years", likening her to
Audrey Hepburn. On review aggregation website
Rotten Tomatoes, Season 1 has a 94% approval rating based on 53 reviews. The site's consensus reads, "Effectively avoiding cliche and cheesy exposition,
My So-Called Lifes realistic portrayal of the average American girl is ahead of its time". On
Metacritic, which assigns a
weighted average rating, the show has a score of 92 out of 100 based on 19 reviews, indicating "universal acclaim". It is the 20th highest rated television series on the website. In 2007, it was listed as one of
Times "100 Best TV Shows of All-
TIME". It was number 33 on
Entertainment Weeklys "New Classics TV" list of shows from 1983 to 2008, and as number 8 in the "25 Greatest Cult TV Shows Ever".
TV Guide ranked the series number 16 on its 25 Top Cult Shows Ever list in 2004, as well as number 2 on its 2013 list of 60 shows that were "Cancelled Too Soon".
Awards and nominations Ratings For its original run in the United States, the show aired on Thursday nights at 8 p.m. ET against top-10 hit sitcoms —
Mad About You and
Friends on
NBC, as well as the popular
Martin,
Living Single and
New York Undercover on
Fox, possibly contributing to the series' low ratings. The producers said that they could not fault ABC for the creative freedom and support they gave them during production, as there were probably few networks that would have even put
My So-Called Life on the air in the first place. Although
My So-Called Life drew adult fans in addition to teenage viewers, the ratings-focused ABC concluded not enough viewers of a particular demographic were watching the show during its initial network run. Holzman said, "It is one thing to have huge ratings, but it is quite another to have smaller ratings but with an extremely passionate following. I don't understand why the network did not understand that." When the network was considering canceling the show, producers Zwick and Herskovitz appealed to then-ABC President
Bob Iger, telling him, "You should keep this show on the air because teenage girls have no voice in our culture, and the show is giving them a voice." In January 1995, it was reported the show averaged 10 million viewers per week, a number ABC president of entertainment
Ted Harbert said was high, but still fell short compared to ABC sitcom
Home Improvement, which averaged 30 million viewers weekly.
Cancelation An online
fan campaign attempted to save
My So-Called Life, the first such event in the history of the
World Wide Web. Bolstered by fans' support, Ted Harbert said he was prepared to bring the show back for a second season. In a 2004 interview with
Entertainment Weekly, Danes insisted that she did not have enough power to cause the cancelation by herself. It is generally accepted that the show's cancelation was the result of a variety of factors, including low ratings and scant publicity from the network.
Bess Armstrong said, "Actually, I don't think there were any bad guys. It was just a confluence of events. It was a perfect storm." Winnie Holzman theorized that the network was so on-the-fence about renewing the show in the first place that in some ways they used Danes' reluctance to return as a convenient excuse to not renew the series. ==Episodes==