After 1837 the Society began to decline. Even after it was decided to introduce music by foreign composers, in the hope of creating more general interest in the concerts, it failed to restore the Society to prosperity; after another period of far from successful management, a special appeal for support was made at the close of 1854. At that date the members included
Henry Charles Banister, Sterndale Bennett,
H. Blagrove, J. B. Calkin, C. Coote, J. T. Cooper, W. H. Holmes,
C. E. Horsley,
H. Lazarus,
E. J. Loder,
Kate Loder,
C. Neate,
W. S. Rockstro, C. Severn,
C. Steggall,
C. E. Stephens, J. W. Thirlwall, H. J. Trust, J. Weslake, H. Westrop, J. Zerbini, and Sir
George Smart. This effort was ridiculed in
The Musical World of 16 December 1854, on the ground that the Society had no true claim to its title, as many composers and artists of note held aloof from it. The special appeal served however to draw some new friends to the ranks; as a means of fulfilling its objectives, prizes were offered for chamber compositions, which were gained in 1861 by
Ebenezer Prout and Edward Perry for string quintets; in 1863 by J. Lea Summers and W. Gibbons, also for string quintets; and in 1864 by Ebenezer Prout and J. Lea Summers, for quartets for piano and strings. The umpires on these occasions included
Joseph Joachim,
Bernhard Molique,
Carlo Alfredo Piatti, Cipriani Potter, G. A. Macfarren,
A. Mellon, T. M. Mudie and
H. Leslie; the prize works were publicly performed by
Agnes Zimmermann, Joseph Joachim, A. Mellon, H. Webb,
J. T. Carrodus, W. Watson,
J. T. Willy, W. T. Aylward, and Carlo Piatti. In 1865 the Society was dissolved, its library was sold by Messrs. Puttick & Simpson, and C. E. Stephens was appointed custodian of the minute-books and other documents. ==Society's officers and locations==