AllMusic rated the album favorably, although it noted that it "works almost like a retrospective of a period in the band's career."
Trouser Press wrote that "the combo delivers succinct but clunky punk rock highlighted by unexpectedly strong pop hooks and occasionally odd instrumental angularities."
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music praised Slant 6's ability to "tackle topical subjects from unexpected angles." Reviewing the 2014 reissue, the
Washington City Paper wrote: "Though her voice was occasionally hidden behind distorted guitars and nasal delivery, [Christina] Billotte was still a better singer than many of her ‘90s contemporaries, a fact that’s perhaps more evident on the remaster." Including
Soda Pop * Rip Off on its list of essential riot grrrl albums,
Rolling Stone wrote that the band "held up the capital city’s end with grooves like 'Time Expired,' goofing on Nuggets-style Sixties garage rock but with a sense of menace."
Pitchfork called it "an enduring model of punk rock poise."
Evelyn McDonnell and
Elisabeth Vincentelli, writing for the
New York Times in 2019, considered
Soda Pop-Rip Off "arguably the best album of the riot grrrl era." ==Track listing==