Soft Sounds from Another Planet received widespread acclaim from music critics who praised its experimental production, eclectic range of genres and subject matter of grief and love. It received a
weighted score of 83 out of 100 from review aggregate website
Metacritic, indicating "universal acclaim", based on 20 reviews from
music critics. Reviewers lauded Zauner's vocals and the album's expanded sonic palette in comparison to
Psychopomp. Nathan Reese of
Pitchfork deemed the album's lead single, "Machinist" the band's "biggest leap forward in terms of sound" and favorably compared Zauner's vocals to shoegaze band
Slowdive. No Ripcord's Juan Edgardo Rodriguez also complimented the eclectic range of genres on the album and opined Zauner to be "at her best when she builds upon her aching vocal delivery". Tim Sendra of
AllMusic considered the album an improvement over
Psychopomp and praised the songs', "spacious, expansive sound that envelops the listener in warmth (even when the
synths get a little chilly.)"
Under the Radar's Stephen Mayne praised the album's nuanced perspective on romance and suggested that audiences "looking for something more beautiful need look no farther than what Zauner is already offering."
The Quietus' Veronica Irwin praised the album for retaining the "heartfelt intensity" of its predecessor and Japanese Breakfast's relatable lyrics while expressing surprise at the record's sonic experimentation. Some reviewers meanwhile criticized the album's perceived unevenness. Brian Shultz of
The A.V. Club said, "And while everything on Japanese Breakfast's proper sophomore effort isn't entirely fresh, and its structure is somewhat loose, there's a confidence and crispness to
Soft Sounds that shows just how fully realized Zauner's formerly homemade experiments have become."
Exclaim!s Ian Gormely noted the album's lack of focus but wrote, "In trying to put a wall between herself and her audience, she's opened a new, far more revealing side to her music and herself."
Accolades ==Track listing==