The album was recorded at
The Wool Hall (the band's own studio) in 1984. Conceptually and musically, it further developed the band's sound from the previous studio album
The Hurting (1983), expanding the use of guitars in addition to their electronic sound and imparting a wider approach overall. Early songs written for the album included "Head over Heels", "The Working Hour", and "Mothers Talk", which was released months before the album as a single. These songs, as well as "We Are Broken" (the B-side to "
Pale Shelter" and now segued with "Head over Heels" due to the shared musical motif), were all performed on Tears for Fears' December 1983 tour that featured in ''In My Mind's Eye
. "Mothers Talk" was originally recorded in early 1984 with producer Jeremy Green, but was discarded as the record company disliked it, eventually bringing back The Hurting'' co-producer
Chris Hughes back into the fold. Recording officially began in April 1984, with the album taking eight months to complete, including a month of mixing at Union Studios in Munich. Both singles "
Mothers Talk" and "
Shout" would take the longest to complete, taking up to half the album's production time. "
I Believe" was influenced by the songwriting of
Robert Wyatt, and was originally intended for him to record but the band recorded it themselves. "Broken" is a reworking of the earlier "We Are Broken" and a studio version and a live reprise bookends the song "Head over Heels". The largely instrumental "Listen" has been described as a
symphonic piece. Lyrically, the psychological themes on
The Hurting were continued and extended to include a variety of themes such as politics, war, money, and love. Near the end of the completion of the album, Roland Orzabal played two simple chords on his acoustic guitar that formed the foundation of the song "
Everybody Wants to Rule the World". Although he was initially not interested in working on it, Orzabal was convinced to write a song based on the two chords and he added the chorus line. The song was completed in about a week and was the last track recorded for the album. == Release ==