Catfights and Spotlights debuted at number eight on the
UK Albums Chart with first week sales of over 23,000 copies, becoming their fifth studio album to reach the top ten in the United Kingdom. However, it also became their first album since their debut
One Touch (2000) not to peak inside the national top three. The album fell out of the top fifty in its fourth week of release. In the week of 19 January, the album jumped 22 places from 96 to 74 with sales 2,000.
Catfights and Spotlights was eventually certified Gold by the
British Phonographic Industry (BPI) on 7 November 2008. In
Greece, the album entered at number 33, before dropping to number 37 the following week. However, on its third week the album climbed to number 22. In an interview with
Daily Star Sunday, Sugababes member Range blamed their music label,
Island Records, for disappointing sales of
Catfights and Spotlights. According to Range, "The sales have been disappointing but I don't think it is a reflection on the album's quality, and the problem is the promotion, I don't actually think our fans know we've even got an album out." In a 2009 interview with
The Guardian, Buchanan further elaborated: "We're still really proud of [
Catfights and Spotlights], even though it wasn't our most successful album [...] I was surprised – I think
Change should've got those bad reviews, because that was a lot poppier. With
Catfights, we decided to go a bit old-school and stripped-back. But if we stayed in the place we were in, we'd never move on." == Track listing ==