The second St Matthew's was built on the present site in
Stirling Square and was consecrated by
Bishop Hale on 21 September 1860. That brick building with a roof of shingles was destroyed in a hurricane on 12 March 1872 during a baptism. No-one was hurt but only the
harmonium and a few books could be saved. Parishioners immediately started a rebuilding programme and the present church of St Matthew was opened on 9 June 1873, and consecrated on 15 October 1873. A second-hand pipe organ was installed in 1875. This organ had been built for
St. John's Church, Fremantle, but became redundant when they purchased a larger instrument. A much larger pipe organ was installed in the church in 1911, replacing the earlier organ by R C Clifton. This new organ was built by the Adelaide builder
J. E. Dodd. The organ has encountered many re-buildings over the years, but has been kept in remarkable condition. In 2004 the organ was fully rebuilt and now features a state of the art transmission system. ==References==