, 1836 The painting is traditionally attributed to
Philipp Veit. He had already completed a depiction of Germania in 1836. This earlier Germania, however, is not standing but sitting and appears to be melancholic. It is to be seen as a retrospective reference to the
Middle Ages, less as a combative symbol for the present. According to Rainer Schoch, the type and allegorical language of the Paulskirche painting is "obviously" based on Veit's 1836 painting. Around 1900, various individuals recorded in their memoirs that the Paulskirche painting had been made from a drawing by Veit. According to the son of
Eduard von Steinle, a painter friend of Veit's from the
Nazarene circle, his father had created the picture for St Paul's Church in a few days. This happened shortly after the election of the
Reichsverweser (29 June 1848). Friedrich Siegmund Jucho was the "custodian of the estate" of the National Assembly and the saviour of the constitutional document. According to him, the picture was "painted by local artists". The pre-parliament, a convention that discussed the election of the actual parliament, had already donated it for the Paulskirche. In fact, the picture can already be seen on a
lithograph of the Pre-Parliament (around 1 April). The National Assembly, on the other hand, met for the first time only on 18 May. Eduard von Steinle and his friends in the artist circle
Deutsches Haus painted several Germania pictures in 1848. Perhaps the Paulskirche Germania is based on a design by Steinle that is thought to have been lost. The art historian Rainer Schoch considers a joint production possible in which Veit, Steinle and other artists of the
Deutsches Haus were involved. This may have included Karl Ballenberger, by whom a Germania is also known. == Context of presentation ==