Film Weekly wrote: "Michael Powell is the man who makes things move in this somewhat crude but effective 'three-quarter' size talkie. His direction of an ordinary story, and the deft manipulation of his players, is ingenious and enterprising, and the entertainment values of
The Star Reporter owe much to him." ''Today's Cinema'' assessed it as: "cleverly directed on the lines of swift action, snappy dialogue and varied settings."
Picturegoer wrote: "Pretentious and fantastic story of a smash-and-grab raid, with a newspaper reporter – following the American tradition – bringing the crooks to justice. It is all very ingenuous and is chiefly notable for the introduction of Isla Bevan, a new star, who looks like making good. Garry Marsh and Harold French both put up good performances, and the picture generally is quite fairly entertaining, if one is not too critical." ==References==