Joey Esposito of
IGN described the series as "a crossover that genre fans have been awaiting for decades". Reviewing the first issue, he predicted that the "near-
photorealistic" artwork would prove controversial among readers. He rated the issue 7 out of 10. Paul Mount of
Starburst was negative in his assessment, stating in his review of issue 7: "If IDW are tempted to cross-pollinate these two sci-fi giants again, they might want to take a bit more time to come up with a story which makes the writing, drawing and reading of it worth the effort, because this just has the stink of a lazy vanity project about it, and fans of both franchises were undoubtedly expecting and deserving quite a bit more." A 2024
Den of Geek article commented that the comic series had been "a good demonstration of the potential rewards and pitfalls of a
TARDIS/
Enterprise team-up", noting that while it offers some "neat ideas" and "good
fan-servicey bits", its main weakness lies in the characterisations: "[T]he Doctor and the
Enterprise crew quickly become just too damn chummy."
ComicBook.com commented that while "extremely fun to read", the series "also revealed the difficulties of balancing two enormous franchises and their respective tones." It was pointed out that as the
Doctor Who TV series had included verbal references to
Star Trek, the comic writers "had to invent a suitably elaborate '
universes merging' explanation to smooth things over" and maintain
continuity. ==References==