The Boston Globe noted that Hart's "flexible, tar-and-whiskey voice conveys as much personality as his fret work".
The Province determined that Hart "winds up sounding not terribly unlike a toned-down Little Feat or a little above a run-of-the-mill blues rock power trio."
The Scotsman opined that "the instrumentals sound a bit like unfinished backing tracks, but there's a rousing swagger which makes the whole thing hard to resist." The
Calgary Herald said that "
Start with the Soul doesn't push any boundaries or forge any new musical territory... It merely adds another brick to the already-tired wall of American blues rock."
The Irish Times praised the album's "power, poise and skill".
The New York Times considered
Start with the Soul to be one of the best albums of 2000, concluding that Hart "has an uncooked voice and a stance all his own... Jim Dickinson's production makes this real living blues."
The Commercial Appeal thought it was one of 2000's best albums, labeling it a "classic that confounded all the right people and delighted the rest." The
Miami New Times stated that
Start with the Soul was the album of the year. ==Track listing==