Two members of Curtiss A bands replaced two members of
the Replacements.
Bob Dunlap, now known as "Slim," replaced guitarist
Bob Stinson, who was fired in 1986 after the tour for
Tim and died at age 35 in 1995. when their just-released album
All Shook Down happened to be in his car's CD player—loudly when Foley turned on the ignition. The band as well as observers knew at the time that it was self-destructing. was poor and they broke up, perhaps because Westerberg was in pursuit of a solo career, or they just quit. At number 69 (''
Don't Tell a Soul reached 57) on the Billboard
200, All Shook Down'' was the Replacements' second-best-selling album. It received four stars from
Rolling Stone, who called the Replacements "America's best band".
Allmusic didn't like it but gave the album four and a half stars, and, undated, appears to predict the band's breakup. Early on, the Replacements refused to make videos but later made commercial videos for Sire and
MTV. When Warner's
Rhino released four early Replacements albums from Twin/Tone in April 2008, Stinson and Westerberg discussed a reunion in
Billboard. Which drummer they had in mind might be unknown. Stinson had praised Foley's work, which was on beat rather than behind it like Mars. Practice in October 2008 was with
Michael Bland. ==Later years==