In July 2021, Ruch went on leave after making what he called “regrettable errors” in handling cases of sexual abuse in the diocese. The leave of absence followed disclosures that Mark Rivera, lay catechist at Christ Our Light Anglican Church in
Big Rock, Illinois, had been arrested in 2019 and charged with felony sexual assault and predatory abuse of a victim under 13 years of age. Since 2019, over a dozen survivors have come forward with accounts of abuse by Rivera. Their allegations included rape, assault, child sexual abuse, indecent exposure, and grooming. Rivera was sentenced to 15 years in jail on March 6, 2023, and another 6 years was added to his sentence on April 12, 2023. In June 2021, a former congregant of Christ Our Light, Joanna Rudenborg, alleged on Twitter that she had been raped twice by ACNA catechist Mark Rivera and that Ruch, along with other Diocesan leaders, had mishandled the allegations years prior. In response to her allegations, ACNAtoo was formed as an anti-abuse advocacy group. Later that month, Bishop Ruch first informed the Diocese of Upper Midwest congregations about the allegations against Rivera, nearly two years since learning of the first assault claims. Rivera had previously held multiple volunteer roles at
Church of the Resurrection, where Ruch served as rector and then as bishop.
Investigations Following the events of June 2021, the ACNA launched two parallel investigations — one into the accusations against Rivera and the diocese's response and another into allegations that Ruch and other ACNA leaders had created a culture of coercion and control in the Diocese of the Upper Midwest.
Ecclesiastical trial After the investigations were concluded in 2022, two sets of charges, known as presentments, were filed against Ruch. On January 31, 2023, Ruch challenged the validity of the first presentment, halting the process until Archbishop
Foley Beach publicly addressed Ruch's appeal. On August 15, 2023, and November 6, 2023, the
Anglican Church in North America announced that the two presentments against Bishop Ruch would advance to an
ecclesiastical trial. The Ruch trial began in July 2025 on four charges: • Habitual Neglect of the Duties of the Bishop’s Office in Violation of Canon IV.2.10; • Conduct Giving Just Cause for Scandal or Offense including Abuse of Ecclesiastical Power in Violation of Canon IV.2.4; • Conduct that Violates a Bishop’s Ordination Vows, Canon IV. 2.3; • Disobedience, or Willful Contravention of the Canons of this Church or of the Constitution or Canons of the Diocese in Which He Holds Office, Canon IV.2.9. Ruch was found not guilty of all charges by the court in December 2025.
Lawsuit The mother of the child assaulted by Rivera filed a lawsuit on May 18, 2022, in Kane County, Illinois, against Christ Our Light Anglican Church arguing that the child experienced mental anguish and emotional and physical pain because of the church's negligence, and requests over $50,000 in damages. The lawsuit also names several other ACNA entities as respondents in discovery, including the Diocese of the Upper Midwest, Church of the Resurrection (the diocesan cathedral where Rivera previously attended and volunteered), the Greenhouse Movement (the church planting organization that oversaw Christ Our Light Anglican) and the
Anglican Church in North America. The case is co-counseled by longtime sexual abuse attorney Boz Tchividjian and Chicago attorney Evan Smola. ==References==