Critical response Film critic
Glenn Erickson is positive about the film, writing, "
Strange Impersonation is a fun oddity, a female version of
The Scar (
Hollow Triumph) (or perhaps
The Woman in the Window) but without an organized crime angle. It's the kind of
Cornell Woolrich yarn that depends on an unlikely but entertaining twist concept. ... The future director of
El Cid and a half-dozen landmark
James Stewart westerns shows a flair for dramatic confrontations.
Strange Impersonation never looks cheap even though its limited cast works in just a few sets. Not surprisingly, the underlying message implies that if professional women want to be happy, they need to stop working and marry." Writing in
The Crime Films of Anthony Mann, Alvarez says, "Irrespective of his reservations and despite its unsatisfying conclusion, the picture is an ingenious and frenzied little thriller". William Darby, who wrote
Anthony Mann: The Film Career, said that the film "uneasily moves between film noir and woman's picture with the latter tendency ultimately winning out." ==References==