laut.de editor Elias Raatz observed that
Strong Girls Club was ambitious in concept but ultimately fell short in execution, delivering overproduced, interchangeable pop with little personal identity. He noted that while tracks like the title song and her duet with
Beatrice Egli offered moments of empowerment and solid musicality, the album's ballads exposed Engels’ vocal limitations and lacked emotional depth. Overall, Raatz described the album as "musical speed-dating without a match."
mix1.de concluded: "Anyone looking for honest lyrics, strong melodies, and a soundtrack for all of life’s moments should not miss
Strong Girls Club." ==Commercial performance==