Sugar at the Gate was claimed by
NARC Magazine to be TOPS' best album: "The satisfying blend of well-timed chord changes, floating synths and featherlike drum beats create something that handsomely rewards repeated listens, especially on the sunnier days." and the 44th best by
Blare magazine. It was also one of the "Favorite Indie Pop and Indie Rock Albums" of
AllMusic, which published a review by Marcy Donelson that concluded, "If a touch weightier in tone, the album returns a distinctive palette and home-recorded finish to a heavy-heartedness firmly established on 2014's
Picture You Staring, so fans and sentimentalists may take heart." The band's continued attention to song craft was a common praise in reviews of
Sugar at the Gate, and "DIY sometimes suggests the heedless jettisoning of any frills" (
Nows Mark Streeter). In mixed reviews,
DIYs Laura Prior appreciated the use of melancholic lyrics and the "indifferent" delivery of them with an upbeat sound
Mojo dismissed the record as "largely insubstantial," ==Track listing==