There have been numerous notable incidents during the various festivals. In 1977, director
Lino Brocka walked out of the awarding ceremonies at the Metropolitan Theater when
Celso Ad. Castillo's
Burlesk Queen starring
Vilma Santos won eight of the ten awards including the
Best Picture award during the
3rd Metro Manila Film Festival. Brocka reportedly threw invectives at
Rolando Tinio, who was the chairman of the panel of judges of the festival. In 1978, the board of jurors decided to not award honors for
Best Actor,
Best Actress,
Best Supporting Actor and
Best Supporting Actress on the
4th Metro Manila Film Festival. Instead, the jurors gave
Nora Aunor a "Best Performer" award for her role in the movie
Atsay. Aunor beat Vilma Santos, whom fortune-tellers on the then-popular talk show of
Inday Badiday and many moviegoers predicted would win the award for her role in the movie
Rubia Servios. When Nora accepted her award, she cried "Mama, mali ang hula nila" ("Mama, their prediction is wrong") in an apparent reference to the fortune-tellers. In 1983, during the awards night of the
9th Metro Manila Film Festival, many were surprised after
Coney Reyes won the
Best Actress award for the movie
Bago Kumalat ang Dugo and
Anthony Alonzo won the
Best Actor award for the same movie, besting acting greats
Charito Solis,
Phillip Salvador, and Vic Silayan, who were all in the movie
Karnal. In addition, the jury's standards of giving Willie Milan the
Best Director award against Lino Brocka was questioned. In 1986, for the first time, the
12th Metro Manila Film Festival did not give out the traditional first and second
Best Picture awards as well as the other two categories:
Best Story and
Best Screenplay. One of the jurors,
Tingting Cojuangco stated: "No one of the seven entries deserved these awards..." She added that they: "...would like to express [their] concern over the current state of the Philippine movie industry as reflected in the entries to the year's MMFF...[The entries] failed to reinforce and inculcate positive Filipino values by portraying negative stereotypes, imitating foreign films and perpetuating commercially-oriented movies...". In 1988 during the award-giving ceremony of the
14th Metro Manila Film Festival, stuntman and character actor-turned-filmmaker Baldo Marro won the
Best Actor for the film
Patrolman, which also won him the
Best Director award. In fact, he was not known before this. He bested prizewinning director
Chito Roño of
Itanong Mo Sa Buwan in the division, sending uproar from well-meaning critics and regular local film observers. Nevertheless, the announced
Best Director award went to
Laurice Guillen. In 1993, during the "Gabi ng Parangal" of the
1993 Metro Manila Film Festival, the list of winners was supposedly leaked. In 1994, during the "Gabi ng Parangal" of
20th Metro Manila Film Festival held in PICC, the six major awards (
Three Best Pictures,
Gatpuno Antonio J. Villegas Cultural Awards,
Best Director, and
Best Screenplay) were not given as
Alejandro Roces, chairman of the Board of Jurors announced that "none of the entries was deserving". In 2002, the cast of the film ''
Dekada '70 walked out of the award ceremonies after Lualhati Bautista failed to win the Best Story and Best Screenplay awards. Even more controversial was the decision of the judges to name first-timer Ara Mina the Best Actress for her role in Mano Po, beating multi-awarded Vilma Santos, who was in Dekada '70
. In addition, the producers of the films Spirit Warriors: The Shortcut and Lastikman protested the non-inclusion of the two films as official entries, prompting the Festival committee to extend the annual event. Consequently, the committee extended the film screenings to seven days to accommodate two more films which did not make it to the entries. Chito Roño, director of Second Best Picture Dekada '70
, expressed wonder as to why Spirit Warriors
was named the Third Best Picture award if the officials disqualified it as an official entry. The production team of Ang Agimat: Antin-Anting ni Lolo
was also appalled at the decision of the jurors to give the Best Visual Effects award to Spirit Warriors'' if they only use "mono", beating their use of the more advanced "
Dolby Digital system". In 2005, director
Joel Lamangan walked out after he lost to
Jose Javier Reyes. Lamangan failed to win the
Best Director for
Blue Moon against Reyes'
Kutob. In the same year,
Regal Films's matriarch
Lily Monteverde voiced out her disappointment as she lamented that some winners in the festival were "undeserving". In 2006,
Octoarts Films and M-Zet Production's
Enteng Kabisote 3: Okay Ka, Fairy Ko: The Legend Goes On and On and On was declared the
Best Picture after festival organizers changed the criteria for the award by giving more weight to "commercial appeal". As it was the only prize that the film won, the decision to let the film receive it became the subject of yet another controversy at the festival. Movie producer
Star Cinema made a protest to the
MMDA and wrote to then MMFF chairman
Bayani Fernando, claiming that the movie
Kasal, Kasali, Kasalo should have won
Best Picture because it topped the box office for the first few days. In 2007, the awards night ended in less than an hour after festival organizers decided to just announce the winners without even mentioning the nominees for each category. The organizers explained that it had to be rushed and had to end at exactly 9pm because a concert, featuring singer
Lani Misalucha, was scheduled right after the awards ceremonies. In 2011, Amable "Tikoy" Aguiluz declined to accept the award for Best Director for the movie
Manila Kingpin: The Asyong Salonga Story after he claimed that the movie "was edited without his consent beyond his recognition." In 2014, Rina Navarro, one of the producers of
Bonifacio: Ang Unang Pangulo questioned the result of the panel's judgement in the awards night. The movie won the
Best Picture award but failed to win other major categories such as the
Best Director award, the
Best Actor and
Best Actress awards, the
Best Screenplay award, and the
Best Original Story award all of which went to Dan Villegas'
English Only, Please. In 2015, a day before the awards night,
Erik Matti's
Honor Thy Father was disqualified for the
Best Picture award after being screened at the
Cinema One Originals. Dondon Monteverde, the film's producer, revealed that they did disclose this information beforehand. He attested that its premiere at the
Cinema One festival did not generate revenue which complies by the rules. He also questioned the timing of this decision and demanded an investigation. In 2016, the festival gained attention after its executive committee announced the top 8 entries for the 2016 edition. Different from past years, the movies of certified box-office drawers
Vice Ganda &
Coco Martin's
The Super Parental Guardians,
Vic Sotto's
Enteng Kabisote 10 and the Abangers,
Regal Entertainment's
Mano Po 7: Tsinoy and
Vhong Navarro's
Mang Kepweng Returns were rejected in that edition. This was the first edition of the festival that showed only independent films. But despite good reviews about the 8 entries, the film festival only grossed , or a drop from
2015 Metro Manila Film Festival's . This led to commercial films returning to the festival the following year. ==Scope==