The PC version received "generally favorable reviews", while the PlayStation 2 version received "average" reviews, according to the
review aggregation website
Metacritic. Jason White of
AllGame gave the original PlayStation 2 version three stars out of five, saying, "In the end,
Summoner is a decent first effort on the part of Volition. It looks beautiful, contains many hours of gameplay, and can be fun. Is it one of the top role-playing games available for home consoles? Hardly, but those hungry for an RPG on their PlayStation 2 should be able to live with the faults." Christopher Allen later gave the PC version three-and-a-half stars, saying, "As a complete package,
Summoner is playable and a better than average addition to the RPG genre. The particle effects for the spells and treatment of the landscapes are well done, but graphics alone don't make the game. A lethargic storyline and cast of 2D characters becomes slightly tiresome and players are not compelled to advance to the next chapter. The game admirably attempts to overcome these challenges, but in the end simply isn't engaging enough for all but the most dedicated gamers. The groundwork was laid for a unique experience, but
Summoner fails to clear its self-imposed bar." David Ryan Hunt of
Computer Games Strategy Plus gave the same PC version a similar score of three-and-a-half stars, saying, "With a strong plot, good multiplayer, lots of items to find, things to do and places to explore,
Summoner provides an acceptably entertaining experience, but it lacks anything truly original that might elevate it into the realms of a truly memorable game. As a final note, it has a rather... ah, interesting... pen and paper RPG script after the credits. You have to see it to understand." The PlayStation 2 version won the award for "Best Story" at
GameSpots Best and Worst of 2000 Awards. The PC version was later nominated for the "Best Single-Player Role-Playing Game" and "Best Story" awards at the website's Best and Worst of 2001 Awards, but lost to
Wizardry 8 and
Anachronox, respectively. The former console version also won the awards for Role-Playing Game of 2000 and Storyline of 2000 at
IGNs Best of 2000 Awards. According to
PC Data,
Summoner sold 120,000 units in 2000 for the PlayStation 2. ==Sequel==