The
New York Times called it "inventive and chic. Only the substance is familiar and thin."
Walter Kerr called it a "sentimentalised farce... precisely the kind of echo chamber exercise that drives intelligent young theatregoers to complete despair."
Variety wrote "the show has ribtickling lines and farcical situations." Another review in the same magazine called it "a synthetic, frivolous, amusing comedy." Redford later said he liked the jokes but felt the play was "not up to the standard of a Kanin-Gordon script". However the
New York Times review was positive enough to ensure a semi-decent run and give Redford his first significant stage success. He was given a
Theatre World Award for his performance. ==See also==