Formation and the early years The club was formed on 5 March 1898 when Sutton Guild Rovers F.C. and Sutton Association F.C. (formerly Sutton St Barnabas F.C.) agreed to merge during a meeting at the Robin Hood Hotel. The club gained a reputation locally in junior leagues, including the Clapham League, and in 1910 decided to become a senior side.
Athenian League Sutton gained election into the
Athenian League in 1921. and so organised competitions were rare and sporadic, but Sutton won a number of honours. This put them in good stead for winning the league again when the war came to an end. With the help of 42 goals from
Charlie Vaughan, Sutton ran away with the 1945–46 season. This was also the first time the club won the
Surrey Senior Cup and got through to the
FA Cup first round. in the third round and went on to play
Don Revie's top flight
Leeds United, one of the best teams in Europe at the time, at
Gander Green Lane. The match saw 14,000 spectators squeeze into the ground and Leeds, with 11 full internationals in the team, won 6–0. Unfortunately, the next decade proved to be one of little success for the club In
a memorable game against Coventry City, Sutton won 2–1 with goals from Tony Rains and Matthew Hanlan, Despite two top-three finishes following the relegation, a quick return to the Conference did not come until Sutton were Isthmian League champions in 1999 under former captain John Rains. Sutton won the
Surrey Senior Cup in 2003 and the following season saw the team start well and recover from a bad spell over the winter to finish second.
Conference South For the 2004–05 season,
The FA planned for the introduction of two new divisions: the
Conference North and
Conference South. Because of Sutton's high finish in the
Isthmian League Premier Division, they were selected to be a founding member of the Conference South. The next three seasons were unremarkable, with Sutton finishing mid-table each time and no real success in cup competitions. and Paul Doswell came in as manager during the 2008 close-season.
Paul Doswell (2008–2019) Sutton finished fifth in their first season back in the
Isthmian League Premier Division and 2nd the following season, losing in both seasons' play-off semi finals to
Staines Town and
Kingstonian respectively. Back in the Conference South for the 2011–12 season, Sutton finished 4th but lost to
Welling United in the play-off semi finals. On 23 April, Sutton defeated
Chelmsford City at home 2–0 and were crowned champions of the National League South with a game to spare. The club's first ever televised league game, broadcast live on
BT Sport, was played against
Tranmere Rovers at
Gander Green Lane on 17 September 2016, a game which Sutton won 1–0. Paul Doswell celebrated his 500th game as manager of Sutton United on 8 October 2016 and the club made a special presentation to him before kick off. In the second round of the 2016–17 FA Cup, Sutton defeated
League Two side
Cheltenham Town 2–1. In the third round, Sutton were drawn at home to local rivals
AFC Wimbledon of
League One, attracting a crowd of 5,013. A 0–0 draw set up a third round replay at
Kingsmeadow which Sutton won 3–1 after coming from behind. On 29 January 2017, Sutton, captained by
Jamie Collins, a part-time
builder, beat
Championship side
Leeds United, 1–0 in the
FA Cup, and reached the 5th round of the competition for the first time. They therefore became only the 9th non-League side to reach the 5th round of the FA Cup since 1945. They hosted
Arsenal in the last 16 of the competition on 20 February which they lost 2–0. The game sparked a betting controversy surrounding the actions of Sutton's reserve goalkeeper
Wayne Shaw, who ate a 'pastry' on the bench after Sun Bets offered odds of 8–1 against him eating a pie during the match. Shaw offered his resignation over the incident. Sutton finished the 2016–17 season mid-table in 12th. In their final game of the 2017–18 season, and in front of a record league attendance of 3,541, Sutton beat
Aldershot Town at home 2–1 to claim a play-off semi-final place and a best ever league finish of third in the fifth tier. In 2018, Sutton were invited to participate in the
2018–19 Scottish Challenge Cup after the competition had decided to include two
National League clubs. On 8 September 2018, Sutton defeated
Airdrieonians by 17 September 2018 in the second round of the tournament. Following a temporary break in mid-March 2019, one month later Paul Doswell resigned after 11 years as manager, as Sutton finished 9th in the league. During that time his achievements included leading the club to two league promotions, a run to the fifth round of the FA Cup, a National League play-off semi-final and a first win for an English team in the
Scottish Challenge Cup. The club also prospered off the pitch with regular match attendances increasing significantly, ground improvements and the formation of an academy for young players.
Promotion to the Football League (2019–2024) On 1 May his successor was announced as
Matt Gray, who had joined the club as head coach in December 2018. This was Gray's first appointment as a full manager. Sutton were ranked 15th when the
2019–20 season was suspended because of the
COVID-19 pandemic. In the following
2020–21 season, Sutton performed strongly throughout and on 23 May 2021 beat
Hartlepool United at home 3–0, winning the National League with a game to spare and securing promotion to the
English Football League for the first time in the club's 123-year history. On 7 August 2021, Sutton played their first English Football League match, losing 2–1 to
Forest Green. Sutton booked their place in the
2022 EFL Trophy final after defeating
Wigan Athletic on penalties. In the final at
Wembley Stadium, Sutton met
Rotherham United, losing 4–2 after extra time. In their first
League Two season, Sutton finished 8th, missing out on the play-offs by one point. They finished 14th at the end of the
2022–23 season. He was replaced with Steve Morrison. In the
2023–24 season, Sutton were relegated from the Football League after finishing in 23rd place.
Back in the National League After a mid table finish in their first season back, Steve Morrison was sacked in October 2025 after Sutton were in the relegation zone with terrible form. He was replaced by Chris Agutter, who dragged the team out of the relegation zone, and the team turned the season around with the 2nd best form in the National League as of 05/11/2025, unbeaten in 8 games in all competitions. ==Club identity==