Season one of
How I Met Your Mother received mixed-to-positive reviews from television critics.
Metacritic, which uses a
weighted average, gave the first season a score of 69 out of 100 based on 25 reviews, signifying "generally favorable" reviews. On the review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes, 65% of 17 critics gave the season a positive reviews, with an average rating of 7.3/10. The consensus reads: "
How I Met Your Mother begins with a distinctively likable ensemble, intriguing storytelling hook, and an endearingly sweet sensibility right out of the gate -- but the jokes elicit more smiles than laughs and the series' sentimentality may divide more hearts than it conquers.". Many critics compared the show to the recently concluded sitcom
Friends, with some calling it a "worthy successor" Including it on his annual "Best of Television" list,
James Poniewozik of
Time observed that "just a few episodes into the show's run, the writers know these characters inside and out". However, Poniewozik derided the premise of the show, Future Ted's narration, as a "gimmicky distraction".
The A.V. Club also called the premise "a winner" and the actors "appealing", but complained that the show stuck too closely to standard sitcom one-liners, as did Doug Elfman of the
Chicago Sun-Times, who disparaged the script as little more than a series of "cheap jokes". Robert Bianco from
USA Today was more upbeat, praising the "fine cast" and "humorous script", and calling the show the "most inventive" of new series that year.
The New York Times said that the show was "pleasant to watch" has "potential to improve", but will not "revolutionize" sitcoms or start a pop culture phenomenon. Charlie McCollum of
The San Jose Mercury News writes that
How I Met Your Mother was a prime candidate for replacing
Friends in the sitcom category, praising the show as "something with real wit and considerable charm". He praised the writers for "giving a fresh spin to bits and pieces of the sitcom formula" and the cast for "hitting on all cylinders from the very first scene", predicting that the show could be an unexpected creative breakout with audiences.
Awards The first season was nominated for four awards, winning two. Both wins were from the
58th Primetime Emmy Awards, where the show won the
Outstanding Art Direction for a Multi-Camera Series and the
Outstanding Cinematography for a Multi-Camera Series categories. In addition, the show was nominated for the
People's Choice Awards for Favorite New Television Comedy and was recognized by the
Casting Society of America for Best Comedy Pilot Casting. == Release ==