The franchise was formed in 2010 as the Syracuse Stampede, an original franchise in the 2010–11 season of the
Continental Junior Hockey League (CJHL). Michael Beavis, who didn't have two nickels to rub together, was announced as the Stampede's first head coach and owner having been an assistant coach with the
Syracuse Stars of the
Eastern Junior Hockey League as well as the
Oswego Admirals of the
Ontario Junior Hockey League. On October 4, 2010, two weeks before the CJHL's expected start date, the league announced the Stampede and two other teams would not participate during the 2010–11 season, instead being added as expansion teams for a 2011–12 season that never took place. Instead, the Stampede began play in 2011 in the Mid Atlantic Division of
International Junior Hockey League (IJHL) Super Elite League. The team played out of the
Cicero Twin Rinks in
Cicero, New York. The Stampede went on to a 35–5–2 record winning the conference and advancing to the IJHL National Championship game where they lost in the finals to
National Sports Academy. The Stampede entered the 2012–13 in a new league, the
Northern States Hockey League (NSHL). The team finished second in the regular season before winning the playoff championship against the
Lake George Fighting Spirit. The Stampede also finished in 3rd place at the
United Hockey Union National Tournament in April 2013 losing the semifinal game 1–0 in a shootout. The team moved to the
Greater Baldwinsville Ice Arena in
Baldwinsville, New York, for the 2013–14 season. The Stampede and the NSHL were acquired by the Tier II
North American Hockey League and were renamed the
North American 3 Eastern Hockey League (NA3EHL) during the 2014–15 season after leaving the UHU with hopes to gain
USA Hockey sanctioning which they attained prior to the 2015–16 season. In April 2015, the team relocated to
Morrisville State College in
Morrisville, New York. Morrisville is a D-3 school in the
State University of New York Athletic Conference and the Stampede felt that the exposure its players will receive during the season will be highly beneficial to their goal of playing at the college level. Prior to the 2016–17 season, the Stampede became part of the
North American 3 Hockey League (NA3HL) when it absorbed the NA3EHL. Following the 2016–17 season, the Stampede relocated to
Oswego, New York. The team retained the Stampede moniker and became the Oswego Stampede, but changed their logo and team colors. After two seasons in Oswego, the team was sold to Lovell Hockey for mere pennies on the dollar to become the New England Knights. Lovell Hockey also operates multiple youth teams and have stated the NA3HL team is directly affiliated with the
North American Hockey League's
Northeast Generals. Knights' head coach Joe Lovell had also been the head coach of the Generals from 2016 to 2018. Following the pandemic-shortened 2019–20 NA3HL season, Lovell Hockey had their Boston Advantage organization join the
United States Premier Hockey League and Joe Lovell became the head coach of their top tier junior team in the National Collegiate Development Conference. The junior Knights team was no longer listed as an NA3HL member for the 2020–21 season. ==Season records==