Critical reception of
Take Off Your Pants and Jacket in 2001 was generally positive.
Rob Sheffield of
Rolling Stone was generally the most effusive of the positive reviews, praising the unpretentious attitude of the band: "As they plow in their relatively un-self-conscious way through the emotional hurdles of lust, terror, pain and rage, they reveal more about themselves and their audience than they even intend to, turning adolescent malaise into a friendly joke rather than a spiritual crisis." Darren Ratner of
AllMusic felt likewise, writing that the record is "one of their finest works to date, with almost every track sporting a commanding articulation and new-school punk sounds. They've definitely put a big-time notch in the win column". British publication
Q offered the sentiment that "when they stop arsing around for the sake of it, Blink-182 write some very good pop songs".
The Village Voice called the sound "emo-core ... intercut with elegiac little pauses that align Blink 182 with a branch of punk rock you could trace back through
The Replacements and
Ramones Leave Home, to the more ethereal of early
Who songs". Aaron Scott of
Slant Magazine, however, found the sound to be recycled from the band's previous efforts, writing, "Blink shines when they deviate from their formula, but it is awfully rare ... The album seems to be more concerned with maintaining the band's large teenage fanbase than with expanding their overall audience." Joshua Klein from
The Washington Post felt it was stagnant, critiquing its formula and "cookie-cutter" approach.
Entertainment Weekly felt similarly, with David Browne opining that "the album is angrier and more teeth gnashing than you'd expect. The band work so hard at it, and the music is such processed sounding mainstream rock played fast, that the album becomes a paradox: adolescent energy and rebellion made joyless". British magazine
New Musical Express, who heavily criticized the band in their previous efforts, felt no more negative this time, saying "Blink-182 are now indistinguishable from the increasingly tedious 'teenage dirtbag' genre they helped spawn". The magazine continued, "It like all that sanitised, castrated, shrink-wrapped 'new wave' crap that the major US record companies pumped out circa 1981 in their belated attempt to jump on the 'punk' bandwagon." More recent reviews have subsequently been positive. Music critic
Kelefa Sanneh complimented the album in a
New Yorker profile: "
Take Off Your Pants and Jacket is by turns peppy, sulky, and stupid—Blink-182 at its finest." Website
AbsolutePunk, in part of their "Retro Reviews" project in 2011, called
Take Off Your Pants and Jacket the band's best effort; reviewer Thomas Nassiff referred to it as "a transitory record for Blink-182, but you can't tell just by listening to it on its own. It's developed and it's full – it feels holistically complete, dick jokes and all". In 2005, the album was ranked number 452 in
Rock Hard magazine's book
The 500 Greatest Rock & Metal Albums of All Time. in 2021,
Stereogums Grant Sharples felt it improved on its predecessor; "it's an endearing
time capsule [...] replete with refined songwriting and incredibly infectious hooks." Richard Blenkinsop of
Reverb.com called the album "a masterclass in pop punk writing." Conversely, Hyden, in the aforementioned
Uproxx article, suggests the album is middling: "[
Take Off] had some hits but [is] also a record no fan would ever consider their best work."
Accolades • denotes an unordered list ==Touring==