In 1999, Kolton was ordained the first Humanistic rabbi by Wine's
International Institute for Secular Humanistic Judaism. She succeeded Wine as senior rabbi at the Birmingham Temple in 2004 following his retirement. and the significant role that officiating interfaith marriages played in her practice. Kolton left her position at the Birmingham Temple in 2012 due to experiencing a strong "spiritual calling" and feeling the need to pursue a more "soul-centered" form of Judaism. She also described significant personal and professional difficulties at the Birmingham Temple, culminating in a "terrible" board meeting during which she reportedly handed in her resignation. She later held the position of scholar-in-residence at Congregation Shir Tikvah in
Troy, Michigan. In 2020, Kolton
self-published her first book,
Oranges for Eve: My Brave, Beautiful, Badass Journey to the Feminine Divine. The book was inspired by her research on the
sacred feminine in Judaism and re-interpretation of the Biblical
Eve as a "Mother of Spiritual Bravery" figure. Kolton's theology after leaving Humanistic Judaism has oriented around feminist re-interpretation of Eve, contextualizing her story as a myth designed to separate women from their personal and spiritual power. ==#MeToo controversy==