The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "This pleasant little comedy provides a gentle skit on village life. Bernard Miles is inclined to make Colonel BartonBarrington just a shade too blimpish, and the same criticism is true of Christopher Steele's vicar, who is just a little too much the stage conception. But for the rest, the village people behave with that faint suspicion of the townsman which is characteristic of them, and the trivial details of village life are picked out and gently mocked. Niall MacGinnis and Rosamund John as the young man and woman are not called upon greatly to exert themselves, but there are neat sketches from Lucie Mansheim as a Russian sniper making a goodwill tour and from John Schofield as a tank driver. Much of the script is above the average of British films, and the location shots are excellent."
Kine Weekly wrote: "Soothing, unhurried romantic comedy drama of the English countryside ... Bernard Miles, who is also co-director tends to overact as the peppery Colonel Barton-Barrington ... The long supporting cast is also good, but it's Mr and Mrs. Tawny Pipit's picture. The close-ups of the Tawny Pipit are delightful, and so are the pictorial backgrounds. The scene of a meeting of the elderly members of the Association, too, is good satire, but much of the village by-play is tinged with obvious propaganda, The rather lumbering frame does not, however, seriously rob the authentic basic portrait of bird-life of instruction or charm."
Variety wrote: "If the Academy had an award for the year's worst titled film, this one would cop the Oscar without a doubt, Despite this handicap,
Tawny Pipit has everything it takes to make a boxoffice hit. The tawny pipit is a rare bird and this fim is frankly a glorification of ornithology. With such a theme, a picture could hardly be expected 'to have much appeal, but it actually has ... Success for the film is assured because of a cast of such established boxoffice favorites ...All are aided by more than usually intelligent direction of Charles Saunders and. Bernard Miles."
The New York Times wrote, "Seldom does such a piece of unsophisticated charm and humor reach the screen, but this is one that is presented in such an utterly beguiling fashion that it would be a grave error not to see it." Rosamund John was later to say, "
Rank didn't think they would be able to sell it to America so it was stashed away for a while. When it was shown, it was wildly popular, because it was everything the Americans thought of as being English." ==References==