Stickles swam with
James Counsilman's
Indiana University team from 1962 to 1965, and as a three-time All American earned Varsity letters in 1962, 1963, and 1964. Between the years 1962–1964, he captured five championships in Big Ten competition in the 200 and 400 Individual Medley events. In National AAU championships in both the 200 and 400 Individual Medley, he won six championships. In the 200 and 400 Individual Medley, he held both American and World records. At one point during his career, he and his roommate,
Chet Jastremski, held a total of seven world records. Stickles broke a total of nine world records in the
individual medley in the early 1960s.
Records • Four world records – 400m individual medley • Eight U.S. National AAU Championships – 200 m individual medley, 400m individual medley
Honors Stickles was inducted into the
International Swimming Hall of Fame in 1995 and into the Indiana University Hall of Fame in 1998. ==Coaching career==