Box office Teen Witch was released in the United States on April 23, 1989, and grossed $3,875 in its opening weekend at the box office, and only $27,843 in its entire run against its production budget of $2.5 million.
April 1989 box office competition included
Field of Dreams starring
Kevin Costner and
Pet Sematary written by
Stephen King. Both films were released on April 21, 1989, two days before
Teen Witch was released.
Critical response Upon release, the film was panned by critics, including Chris Willman of the
Los Angeles Times, who called it "complete with teen wish-fulfillment fantasies, condescending moralizing, asinine musical montages, horrifying pop songs, French kissing, blatant product plugs and Dick Sargent (formerly of
Bewitched)."
TV Guide pointed out the predictability of the film and concluded, "Notwithstanding its supernatural elements, the film is basically a standard teenage love story (a squeaky clean one, at that) with several unmemorable musical numbers thrown in."
Variety wrote "the comedy potential...is limited in this well-intentioned, young teen vehicle burdened by a nice message and a predictable outcome", but said where the film stands out is "its bouncy score, provided by Larry and Tom Weir".
Cult status The film performed much better on home video and overseas. Jarett Wieselman of the
New York Post stated, "There are good movies, there are bad movies, there are movies that are so bad they're good and then there is
Teen Witch – a cult classic that defies classification thanks to a curious combination of songs, spells and skin." There are
parodies or
homages of the film, especially of its rap song "Top That" (including an homage starring
Alia Shawkat). Drew Grant of
Nerve.com stated, "If you've never seen the original rap scene from the 80s classic
Teen Witch, you must immediately stop what you're doing and watch it right now. It's everything wonderful and terrible about that decade rolled into one misguided appropriation of... hip-hop." In a 1998 retrospective review,
Ada Calhoun of
The Austin Chronicle praised the film, calling it "so Eighties it hurts". She added, "Between the dearth of character actors, the valuable lessons learned, and the textbook backfiring of good intentions, some may scoff. They would, however, be in the wrong, for this is a masterpiece of both the teen and witch genres. Louise the nerd, bubbling over with sexual energy and social ambition, becomes cool. Louise the witch, erratically powerful, learns how to rightly use her strength.
Teen Witch is an all-around delicious flick, both despite and because of the
afterschool special quality of its message." In 2007, ABC Family (now
Freeform) acquired the basic cable television rights to the film, and has since made it a regular offering of its annual
13 Nights of Halloween holiday block. ==Soundtrack ==