Written by singer
Mick Jagger and guitarist
Keith Richards, "Tell Me" is a
pop ballad. In a song review for
AllMusic, critic
Richie Unterberger commented, "It should be pointed out... that the Rolling Stones, even in 1964, were more versatile and open toward non-
blues-rooted music than is often acknowledged by critics." The Rolling Stones' two previous singles bear out this observation: one had been the
Lennon–McCartney-penned "
I Wanna Be Your Man" (later recorded by
the Beatles as well); another was
Buddy Holly's "
Not Fade Away". Jagger said in a 1995 interview with
Rolling Stone magazine: "['Tell Me'] is very different from doing those
R&B covers or
Marvin Gaye covers and all that. There's a definite feel about it. It's a very pop song, as opposed to all the blues songs and the
Motown covers, which everyone did at the time." The song's lyrics are a glimpse of a failed relationship and the singer's attempt to win back the girl's love: Unterberger notes, "When [Jagger and Richards] began to write songs, they were usually not derived from the blues, but were often surprisingly fey, slow,
Mersey-type pop numbers... 'Tell Me' was quite acoustic-based, with a sad, almost dispirited air. After quiet lines about the end of the love affair, the tempo and melody both brighten". ==Recording and release==