The album received generally positive reviews from critics. Anne Erickson from
Blabbermouth.net gave the album 8 out of 10 and said: "Of Mice & Men continue to grow and change as a band, and
Tether is a solid piece of their story. While those who prefer more brutal sounding metalcore might be left a bit cold, others who enjoy the genre's massive hooks and melodies will likely be cranking this record for years to come. Even on record eight, Of Mice & Men are staying limber enough to evolve and push the envelope, creatively." Ed Walton of
Distorted Sound scored the album 8 out of 10 and said: "
Tether shows that Of Mice & Men are at the absolute top of their game; it's obvious that each member didn't let a single second go to waste during the recording process and left it all in the studio. Everything about the record is done to almost perfection, although one criticism is that every now and then, particularly on the heavier sounding songs, the vocals sometimes feel like they can get lost amongst the cacophony of sound. Overall though, the album is a welcome return from the metalcore troupe; there is plenty to enjoy for old fans and it will also work as the perfect gateway for new fans they pick up along the way. By the end of it, you'll have your own warpaint ready, hanging on and very likely screaming along to every word." Tom Lamm of
HM stated "Above all, the journey the band orchestrates from start to finish in their latest release reflects their care and intentionality with music, something no OM&M fan will be surprised to hear. Fitting for its name,
Tether will undoubtedly stick with you as a hard-hitting and a triumphant return for the rock giants we know and love." In a more mixed review,
Kerrang! gave the album 2 out of 5 and stated: "Live, these songs will probably find the required juice to make them stand as tall as they might. As it is,
Tether all too often comes across as vague, distant, and in need of a spark to set the whole thing off."
Metal Hammer gave the album a positive review and stated: "
Tether is a reminder that Of Mice & Men are as deliberate in their choice of track order and album cohesion as they are in their songwriting, and it makes for a powerfully immersive journey."
Outburn gave the album 9 out of 10 and stated: "
Tether is not just the band's next step, but an album that showcases seasoned veterans who are technical juggernauts at what they continue to give musically." ''Rock 'N' Load
praised the album saying, "Having always managed to have a great mix between the brutal and melodic side of the genre, not much has changed here although the melodic side seems to shine through more on this one than previous releases." Simon Crampton of Rock Sins
rated the album 8 out of 10 and said: "Tether'' is another string on an already impressively stacked bow and one that showcases what a great band Of Mice & Men have grown into." ==Track listing==