That Old Feeling met with mixed reviews from critics, with a 43% rating on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 14 reviews. Lawrence Van Gelder gave the film a positive review in
The New York Times, calling it a "raucous, high-spirited romantic comedy, which zips along under the direction of Carl Reiner, working from a script by the sharp-witted Leslie Dixon."
Los Angeles Times critic John Anderson stated that it was a "very traditional comedy in a surreal sort of way" and "generally fun, thanks to old pros Midler and Farina, and Nucci, who plays Joey as a combination
Joe Pesci-
Jerry Lewis." Chris Hicks of
Deseret News labelled it "[a] anti-family values comedy", and claimed "the film never quite lives up to its first feisty 15 or 20 minutes." The
Chicago Tribune's Mark Caro criticized the film, writing, "Instead of focusing on how this couple re-explores their relationship after 14 years of estrangement, the movie scatters its attentions among a group of mostly unpleasant characters. Marshall projects a good-humored sweetness as Molly, but Denton's Keith is a stuffed shirt from the start, which is explained by the easy joke that he's a
Republican. Lilly's husband, Alan (David Rasche), is a spineless New Agey therapist, and Dan's wife, Rowena, is a plastic surgery-enhanced shrew portrayed by former
NYPD Blue bombshell Gail O'Grady, who's too young to be playing such a gross caricature." It was subsequently released to
VHS on October 7, 1997, and then to
DVD on April 28, 1998. In January 1998,
Siskel and Ebert included
That Old Feeling on their "Worst Films of 1997" episode. ==References==