The German music magazine
Rock Hard rated
Freak Show 8.5/10. Along with the singles "Abuse Me" and "Freak", they praised the songs "No Association", "Learn to Hate" and "Roses". In his review for
Freak Show,
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, writing for
AllMusic, wrote "Silverchair were slaves to their influences on their debut
Frogstomp, but on their second album [...] they're beginning to show signs of developing their own style. While they may still concentrate too heavily on
Pearl Jam and
Nirvana, they're beginning to fuse the elements together in a more interesting way and are writing stronger hooks.
Freak Show still has its share of mediocre moments [...] but the album shows potential that
Frogstomp never did." Jeff Gorra of
Artist Waves wrote that
Freak Show "truly showed how they had evolved as songwriters ... at just 17-years-old." The album's producer,
Nick Launay, has said that
Freak Show is his favourite Silverchair album. He said: During the recording of
Freak Show they were incredibly wild and young, the energy and adrenaline in the room was like the biggest sugar rush imaginable. Craziest moment: Ben climbing inside a flight case with a movie camera being pushed down the long corridor at Festival Studios by the other two crashing into walls while filming from the inside. Result: black screen, shrieking screams, major damage to the walls. In February 2017, Josh Leeson, writing for
The Newcastle Herald, wrote that "for many Chair fans the tortured anger of
Freak Show remains a treasured edition in the catalogue of Newcastle's finest musical export" and that "20 years on it maintains its own freakish charm in body and soul." ==Legacy and influence==