The songs on the album were largely arranged after Gregg Allman joined the band in
Jacksonville,
Florida in March 1969. Most of the songs were devised from longer, impromptu
jam sessions. The group's style evolved from a mix of
jazz,
country music,
blues and
rock, which was the result of each individual member turning the others onto their particular interests. Trucks introduced Johanson to
the Grateful Dead and
the Rolling Stones; Johanson likewise introduced the group to jazz musicians such as
Miles Davis and
John Coltrane, and Betts did the same with country music and
Chuck Berry. Duane Allman had previously listened to Davis and Coltrane before Johanson's suggestion, and his two favorite songs — Coltrane's version of "
My Favorite Things" and Miles Davis' "
All Blues" — were the basis for the majority of the band's modal jamming, "without a lot of chord changes". The album opens with an instrumental, a cover of
Spencer Davis' "
Don't Want You No More," which had previously been employed on set lists of the Second Coming, Oakley and Betts' former band. Allman and Betts' guitars perform in unison on a five-note melody while Johanson concentrates on his
hi-hat, and the song includes an
organ solo. The song contains two guitar solos, with the latter "[coming] in behind the first one for a darting buildup that sound[s] like something taken from
Brahms". It segues into a "lazy blues shuffle" titled "It's Not My Cross to Bear," which Allman had written in Los Angeles for a former lover. "Black Hearted Woman," also penned on the same subject, follows, and the album returns to a blues-based sound with a cover of "Trouble No More," featuring Duane's debut bottleneck guitar performance. Songs such as "Black Hearted Woman" and "Every Hungry Woman" were written about Allman's experiences with a girl named Stacy in
Los Angeles. Among the most changed were two songs that would become the basis for two of the Allman Brothers' most famed epic concert numbers: "Dreams" and "
Whipping Post". Oakley "played a huge role in the band’s arrangements," changing numbers such as "Whipping Post" from a
ballad structure to a more hard-rocking song. "Dreams" developed from a jam in which the band toyed with the theme to the film
2001: A Space Odyssey, and has been referred to by Johanson as Coltrane's "My Favorite Things" with lyrics. Johanson's drum fills were pulled from
Jimmy Cobb's performance on "All Blues"; he later commented that he "did a lot of copying, but only from the best". "Dreams" begins with "intricate, subdued drums playing under a soft organ with only the hint of guitars before Gregg begins singing about disillusionment and broken dreams". The final song on the record, "Whipping Post," was written shortly after Allman returned to Jacksonville. The song came to him shortly before bed, but he was unable to acquire a pencil and paper to write down his ideas, as there was a child asleep in the room and he could not turn on the lights. Turning to his next best alternative, he struck two kitchen matches (one for light and one, later blown out, as a
charcoal writing utensil) and wrote down his lyrics on a bedside
ironing board. "Whipping Post" was similar in composition to "Dreams" in its first incarnation, with Oakley later creating the heavy
bassline that starts off the track. Duane and Betts take quick solos before the track builds to an "anguished climax," leading to Gregg Allman's solo voice, singing the song's refrain: "Good Lord, I feel like I'm dyin'." Allman had no idea the intro was written in 11/4 time — "I just saw it as three sets of three, and then two to jump on the next three sets with" — until his brother pointed it out for him. "My brother told me — I guess the day I wrote it — he said, 'That's good, man. I didn’t know you understood 11/4.' Of course I said something intelligent like, 'What's 11/4?' Duane just said, 'Okay, dumbass, I'll try to draw it up on paper for you.'"
Gregg Allman's lyrical contributions to the band's debut album have been called "remarkably mature lyrical conceptions for such a young man, expertly executed in a
minimalist, almost
haiku style". Allman's inspiration came from his time in
Los Angeles as a part of
Hour Glass, "getting fucked by different land sharks in the business," experiencing great frustration among fierce competition. The traditional blues songs were, likewise, regarded as "songs that were so good they couldn’t be left off the album". On the writing of the record, Allman wrote in his memoir
My Cross to Bear, "I wrote most of that whole first record in that one week. I had total peace of mind. L.A. and all its changes didn’t even cross my mind. I felt like I was starting all over, which I was." Most of the songs on the album were written at
Rose Hill Cemetery. ==Artwork==