Reviewing
The Bairns for
BBC Music, Mel Ledgard described it as "an album with a cinematic quality, huge in dramatic atmosphere". Nic Oliver, in a 4.5-starred review for
musicOMH, said it was a "remarkable album that is both contemporary and timeless". Iain Hazlewood, for
Spiral Earth, described it as "[a] gorgeously melancholy and sensual album that has raised the bar several notches".
FolkWorld said that
The Bairns is "not your run-of-the-mill folk music. It is fragile and intimate, dark and chilling, with influences from blues and jazz music. It makes you shiver at times, at others uplifting like a vaudeville stage act." Justin Hopper, writing in
Paste, called it "a milestone in English folk music". In a four-starred review,
Robin Denselow of
The Guardian nominated it as "one of the folk records of the year".
The Bairns was nominated for the Best Album award at the
BBC Folk Awards 2008 and was also nominated for the 2008
Mercury Prize. The album debuted in the
UK Top 200 Albums Chart at number 178 in the week after the Mercury Prize award ceremony. ==Track listing==