The three original principal songwriters - Colin Brooks, Ed Jurdi and Gordy Quist - shared the bill at Momo's, an Austin club. Originally, each singer/songwriter performed his own set. However, they eventually started sharing the stage, and collaborating with bassist Seth Whitney. The Wednesday night series was billed as "The Good Time Supper Club". A misprint in a local paper billed the act as "The Heathens". Drummer John Chipman joined the band in 2007, and keyboardist Trevor Nealon, who played in the studio during the recording of both
One Foot in the Ether and ''Top Hat Crown & the Clapmaster's Son'', joined the touring unit in 2011. Their first recording, ''Live from Momo's'', recorded at the now closed club on West 6th Street in Austin brought the band national attention and they were voted "Best New Band" at the 2007 Austin Music Awards. Following the Momo's release, the band released a second live recording, the CD/DVD ''Live at Antone's'' which was recorded at the Austin club. On May 20, 2008, the band released their first, self-titled, studio album. Produced by
Ray Wylie Hubbard, and featuring notable guests
Patty Griffin,
Stephen Bruton, and
Gurf Morlix, the record went to number one on the
Americana Music Association's radio chart. In November 2008 the album was ranked in eighth place on the
Americana Music Association's Top 100 Albums of the Americana Charts for 2008. In July 2009 BOH taped an
Austin City Limits show that aired in late 2009, as ACL was celebrating its 35th anniversary year. The band's unique genesis and creativity were highlighted during the Austin City Limits interview conducted after their performance. The TV performance showcased a set by both the Band Of Heathens and
Elvis Costello. Following the Austin City Limits PBS show, the band also played on the German television live concert series
Rockpalast on October 9, 2009, performing 14 songs, many from the albums
Band Of Heathens and
One Foot In The Ether.
One Foot In The Ether, BOH's second studio release once again charted to the number one slot on the Americana Radio Chart. In 2009, the band was nominated for a "New Emerging Artist" award at the
Americana Music Honors & Awards. In 2010, the band was again honored by the
Americana Music Association as nominees for the "Best Duo/Group of the Year". In 2011, the band released their fifth album overall (third studio album) ''Top Hat Crown & the Clapmaster's Son''. The album was listed in the top 10 most played Americana Albums of 2011, marking the third album in a row to make the year end top 10 list. This album is also the last studio project featuring founding member Colin Brooks, who announced in November that year that he was leaving the band after six years to pursue other interests. 2013 provided the critically acclaimed album,
Sunday Morning Record. The "Bakersfield Californian Review" aptly stated "Sunday Morning Record is a love letter to the past and, at the same time, a postcard to the future." The album charted to the number two spot on the Americana Chart (Americana Music Association) and was selected as the number one album in 2013 by "The Alternative Root". In addition, "The Alternative Root" in referring to its "Top Fifty" Americana Bands stated the following: "The number one spot was the easiest to place. Band of Heathens epitomize Indie, building their band business from the ground up and keeping everything in-house".
Highway Prayer: A Tribute to Adam Carroll, released in late 2016 on Austin-based Eight 30 Records, featured The Band of Heathens' version of Carroll's "Oklahoma Gypsy Shuffler". Additionally, the Band of Heathens' version of "The Dirty South" was included on the satirical album
Floater: A Tribute to the Tributes to Gary Floater, released early in 2018 on the Austin-based Eight 30 Records.
Members ;Current members • Ed Jurdi – vocals, guitars, harmonica, keyboards (2005–present) • Gordy Quist– vocals, guitars, harmonica (2005–present) • Trevor Nealon– keyboards (2011–present) • Clint Simmons– drums (2022–present) • Nick Jay– bass (2022–present) ;Former members • Colin Brooks – vocals, guitars (2005–2011) • Seth Whitney – bass, vocals (2005–2012) • John Chipman – drums, vocals (2007–2012) • Ryan Bowman - bass (2012-2013) • Brian Keane– vocals, keyboards, guitars (2005–2006) • Eldridge Goins – drums, vocals (2005–2006) • Scott Davis– bass, vocals (2013–2017) • Richard Millsap– drums (2012–2022) • Jesse Wilson– bass, vocals (2017–2022) ==Live recordings==