Retro Pop magazine named
The Best Is Yet to Come as Tyler's best album since
Hide Your Heart (1988), noting that Tyler sounds "rested, strong and raring to go." Markos Papadatos of
Digital Journal stated that Tyler "proves that she is like a fine wine, where her harking and heavenly voice only gets better with age and experience," describing the album as "eclectic." In
Belfast Telegraph, Beverley Rouse described
The Best Is Yet to Come as "an enjoyable listen," and commended Tyler for "bringing something different" with her cover of "
I'm Not in Love" by
10cc.
The Scotsman critic Fiona Shepherd called the album "a patchy playlist of covers and originals," but noted "I’m Only Guilty (Of Loving You)" as a strong moment.
Onet Muzyka critic Bartosz Sąder noted that
The Best Is Yet to Come is "not as expressive" as Tyler's previous albums, but that her "hoarse vocal fits perfectly into the style of the 80's-inspired songs." Writing for the Finnish newspaper
Helsingin Sanomat, Mervi Vuorela opined that Tyler would have achieved better results with
hard rock songs instead of
pop rock. ==Track listing==