The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "This modest thriller achieves some excitement and suspense, which are helped out by the antics of the motor-cycle club. A good comedy performance by Leslie Dwyer spices an otherwise unremarkable film."
Kine Weekly wrote: "The picture, unblushing boys' adventure, subtly broadens its appeal by using motor cycle racing and gymkhanas to raise laughs and provide extra thrills, Jimmy Hanley displays a sure sense of humour and sets the right tempo, as Jerry, Rona Anderson has a touch of class as Mary, Leslie Dwyer amuses as the explosive Plack, and Lionel Jeffries is convinciing as Brenner. The concluding reels are great fun and, together with authentic atmosphere and first rate camera work, complete the entertainment oracle."
Picturegoer wrote: "It maintains maximum speed during its sixty-odd minute run."
Picture Show wrote: "Crisp comedy ... Exciting, brisk action with enthusiastic performances from the whole cast."
Britmovie writes that the "plot is seemingly lifted almost intact from the pages of a ''
Boys' Own adventure or the writings of children’s author Enid Blyton. ... Of particular note here is Lionel Jeffries (The Revenge of Frankenstein 1958) as the villain of the piece. Although only in his late 20s, Jeffries already looks much older than his years and effortlessly brings to the role the gravitas it requires. ... Jeffries also succeeds in making A.R. Rawlinson’s mediocre dialogue sound far better than it actually is. ... This is a surprisingly stylish piece of filmmaking overall. Most importantly, Rilla succeeds in keeping the narrative moving at a brisk pace. At a time when low-budget British productions remained resolutely studio-bound, The Black Rider'' features a refreshing amount of exterior footage. Among the lengthiest sequences occurring outdoors is an obstacle course at a fete that takes on an almost newsreel-like quality." According to
TV Guide, "the only thing discomfiting about this film is the poor direction and inept acting". ==References==