Background Hall Caine wrote the first stage version of
The Christian in early 1897. To establish the English copyright, it was given a perfunctory performance on August 7, 1897, at the Grand Theatre on the Isle of Man. Admission was one pound, a colossal sum at the time, to discourage attendance. Caine himself played John Storm, while his wife Mary took the part of Polly Love. Their son
Ralph Caine was Brother Andrew, while Hall Caine's sister, Lily Hall Caine, played Glory Quayle. She was a well-known player in America, but had yet to star in a Broadway production. It was Allen who suggested Hall Caine's dramatization of
The Christian to Tyler. After reading the play, Tyler and Allen agreed she would go to the Isle of Man and persuade Caine to make some changes. Rehearsals began August 22, 1898 under the direction of Walter Clark Bellows. Sets were designed by Louis Young from photos and drawings brought back from Britain by Viola Allen, while
William Furst composed incidental music based on Manx folk melodies she also collected. The theatre was crowded; the author, occupying a box, was cheered by the audience after each act, with the final curtain not falling until after midnight. The audience was "packed to the doors", and required fourteen curtain calls during the evening's performance. One reviewer, while praising the writing and performances, thought the staging could be improved, while also noting the short fourth act was "almost superfluous". Another was disconcerted at the drastic changes from the original novel, particularly John Storm's makeover from a religious fanatic to a soft-spoken everyday priest.
Premiere and reception The Christian premiered at the
Knickerbocker Theatre on October 10, 1898. The reviewer for
The New York Times noted the theatre on opening night was crowded to the doors with no room for late-comers, which they attributed to Viola Allen rather than Hall Caine's talent as a dramatist. The local newspaper in Producer Tyler's hometown of
Chillicothe, Ohio reprinted two New York reviews. The first by
Alan Dale in the
New York Journal said "the first three acts of the play are dismal swamps of talk". Dale felt Glory's transition from simple country girl in the prologue to dazzling music hall success with the first-act opening demanded more in the way of explanation. He did give popular opinion its due: "But the applause at the Knickerbocker was tremendous". in a wing of the Knickerbocker Theatre on November 16, 1898.
Frank Keenan, the stage manager who also played Brother Paul, kept the curtain closed after the third act while asking for any doctors in the house to come backstage. The doctors who responded pronounced her dead. The fourth act curtain opened after a thirty-minute delay without the audience being aware of the death. Marlowe had told other cast members she suffered from heart disease. She was a cousin of the actress
Julia Marlowe. It then resumed its Broadway run at the
Garden Theatre on November 28, 1898. He was replaced with
Henry M. Jewett. The production then moved to the
Boston Museum stage on March 6, 1899. During its first two weeks in Boston the production set a box office record by averaging over $13,000 per week. ==Adaptations==