Controveries about the 1996 Everest disaster abound and
The Climb has received its share of criticism.
Neal Beidleman, one of the three surviving guides of the expedition, stated, “I think that
The Climb is a dishonest account of the May tragedy… [N]either you nor your associates once called to fact-check a single detail with me.” Another one of the three guides who survived the climb,
Michael Groom, was also not interviewed by the authors of
The Climb. Publicist Jane Bromet states in a letter to DeWalt and his publisher that the edited version of her quote that appears in
The Climb is “absolutely wrong!” Bromet wrote, “The distortion will mislead readers into a false conclusion concerning many of the most important factors that led to the accident.“ Boukreev and De Walt defended their book by responding at length to Krakauer and other critics. The controversies about the disaster and the books written about it continued for almost thirty years. In 2025 Jon Krakauer was still defending his book,
Into Thin Air, on
YouTube. ==See also==