The book has received many reviews in newspapers, magazines, periodicals, and scientific journals and has been listed on
The New York Times Non-Fiction Paperback Best Seller list for non-fiction paperback books over two dozen times. Among others, the book was reviewed by
Francesca Russello Ammon,
David Oshinsky,
The Tampa Bay Times, as well as several popular magazines and periodicals, such as
Publishers Weekly,
Slate Magazine,
The New York Review of Books,
The Los Angeles Review of Books,
Kirkus Reviews,
Dissent Magazine, It has also received many reviews in history journals, education journals, and administrative and planning journals.
Reviews In
The New York Times Book Review for the work, written by
David Oshinsky in June 2017, the book is called "a powerful and disturbing history of residential segregation in America". Oshinsky went on to write that "[o]ne of the great strengths of Rothstein's account is the sheer weight of evidence he marshals." After a discussion of the book's insights, Richardson closes the review by stating that the book documents in "appalling detail" the need for
affirmative action as the "remedy for state-sponsored discrimination of the past". In the June 2019 issue of
Jacobin magazine, Richard Walker, a professor emeritus of geography at the University of California — Berkeley, criticized the book for giving outsized blame to federal policy for housing segregation, a conclusion that he said was the result of Rothstein's "dubious scholarship." Wrote Walker, "The fundamental error of this thesis stems from its depiction of racism as a system imposed from above, by the state, rather than something embedded in American social structures since before the founding." Walker states that, while federal housing law "lined up with the prevailing practices of racial segregation … Rothstein's idea that this was
imposed on reluctant localities is ludicrous." Rothstein responded to Walker's critique in the same magazine, criticizing both the content and motivations of Walker's article.
Accolades Among other acclamations of the book, it made the longlist for the 2017
National Book Awards, one of
Bill Gates' favorite books of the same year, and it won Rothstein the
2018 Hillman Prize for Book Journalism. and ending at number ten on June 10, 2018, issue. Following protests in the United States, the book re-entered the list in June 2020. For the book's 23rd consecutive week and 28th total week on the list in the November 22, 2020, issue, the book was placed at number five. As of the December 20th, 2020 issue, the book has spent 32 total weeks on the list. The book's award summary for the
2018 Hillman Prize for Book Journalism argues the work had provided "incontrovertible evidence that it was the laws and policies passed by local, state, and federal governments that actually promoted the discriminatory patterns that continue to this day". After summarizing the topics, the Hillman Foundation went on to note that "Rothstein's invaluable examination shows that relearning this history is a necessary step because it is the foundation for understanding that aggressive policies are in order to desegregate these urban areas and finally pave the way for the nation to remedy its unconstitutional past". == See also ==